Paper Checks May Feel Familiar, But Are They Secure?

FinCEN, the U.S. Treasury’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network, reported that suspicious activity reports related to check fraud almost doubled between 2021 and 2022, increasing from approximately 350,000 reports in 2021 to 680,000 in 2022. In just six months of 2023, financial institutions submitted more than 15,000 reports specifically tied to mail-theft-related check fraud. Those reports represented more than $688 million in attempted or completed fraudulent transactions. 

Checks are often considered a secure way to send payment to vendors and contractors, and, as a result, many organizations continue to send hundreds, or even thousands, of checks each year. The facts, however, tell a different story about the security of our checks. 

The 2026 Association for Financial Professionals Payments Fraud and Control Survey Report supports this concerning trend: 58% of organizations surveyed reported experiencing check fraud in 2025.

How are fraudsters doing this?  

The easiest method used to be check washing. All a fraudster had to do was get ahold of a check in the mail, use a simple household chemical (acetone, bleach, and isopropyl alcohol are all effective) to remove the ink, and rewrite the payee, the amount – or both.

With new technology, though, check cooking has become a trend. Using photo-editing software and a high-quality printer, a fraudster can manufacture multiple fraudulent checks, just by getting ahold of one check.

In a case of check cooking, one stolen check compromises your account number, the routing number, the authorized signature, and your check sequence. Both methods of tampering are fairly simple and easily accessible, making check fraud particularly appealing to fraudsters.  

What can we do to protect ourselves? 

Payment Options and Fraud Prevention Strategies for Organizations

With check fraud creating a significant risk of financial loss, organizations should evaluate alternative payment methods and implement safeguards to protect outgoing payments.

Positive Pay: Protecting Payments Made by Check

For organizations that want to continue paying by check or work with vendors that still require checks, positive pay is an effective check fraud prevention tool that provides additional assurance that payments will reach their intended recipients.

With positive pay, an organization provides its bank with a list of issued check numbers and amounts. Before processing a check, the bank compares it against the information provided by the organization. If the details do not match, the transaction is flagged as an exception, allowing the account holder to review it and determine whether the payment should be authorized.

However, with the prevalence of check washing and alteration, comparing only the check number and amount may not provide sufficient protection. Most banks now offer enhanced positive pay, which also compares the payee’s name against the information on file.

While enhanced positive pay may come with an additional fee, the added comparison provides another level of security against check fraud.

ACH and EFT Payments: Secure Alternatives to Checks

For organizations looking to move away from paper checks, several electronic payment options can help make payments more secure.

One option is to make payments directly through the organization’s banking website using Automated Clearing House (ACH) or Electronic Funds Transfer (EFT). While electronic payments eliminate many of the risks associated with mailing physical checks, they still require strong internal controls.

Organizations should implement the following safeguards for electronic payments:

  • Require dual approval: The employee who enters or uploads a payment should not also have the authority to release it.
  • Limit banking access: Access to the organization’s banking website should be restricted based on employees’ job responsibilities.
  • Enable multi-factor authentication: Require additional identity verification to protect banking access.
  • Use ACH/EFT fraud prevention tools: Ask the bank about options such as ACH/EFT positive pay, ACH debit filters, or an ACH block.

Similar to positive pay for checks, these banking services allow organizations to establish rules around which electronic transactions are authorized to hit their accounts. Transactions that fall outside those rules can be blocked or flagged for review.

AP Automation: Improve Payment Security and Efficiency

Organizations looking to strengthen internal controls while improving efficiency may want to consider an electronic accounts payable (AP) platform, such as BILL, Ramp, or another similar AP automation system.

When implemented correctly, these platforms provide strong payment controls while eliminating many of the manual steps associated with processing and paying invoices.

Invoices can be uploaded or sent directly into the system and routed electronically to the appropriate employees for approval. Payments are issued only after all required approvals are complete.

Organizations can also establish different approval requirements based on dollar amount, department, vendor, or other criteria. This makes it easier to maintain appropriate segregation of duties without slowing down the accounts payable process.

It’s also important to establish controls around adding vendors and changing vendor banking information. These safeguards help prevent payments from being redirected if someone gains access to an employee’s email or submits fraudulent banking instructions.

Integrating AP Automation With Accounting Software

One of the biggest efficiency benefits of AP automation comes from connecting the AP system with the organization’s accounting software.

Depending on the systems being used, transactions can be imported or integrated directly with the general ledger, reducing duplicate data entry and the risk of keying errors.

With an integrated AP automation system, organizations gain:

  • A documented approval trail for outgoing payments.
  • Better visibility into where invoices are in the approval process.
  • A more secure way to pay vendors.
  • Reduced manual data entry and fewer opportunities for errors.
  • Less time spent tracking down approvals, issuing checks, and manually recording payments.

These improvements allow organizations to maintain stronger financial controls and improve payment security while significantly reducing the administrative burden on accounting staff.

Conclusion 

There’s no such thing as a fraud-proof organization, but there are plenty of ways to make your organization a much harder target. Moving away from checks, implementing appropriate controls over the checks that remain, and putting the right controls around electronic payments are all ways to reduce your risk while, in many cases, making the payment process more efficient 

If you’re looking to improve your controls or want to review your payment processes, contact our consulting team.